Who Gets the Camp?
Who Gets the Camp?
It happens every Thanksgiving somewhere up here. Dinner is over, the dishes are drying, and someone asks, half-joking, who is getting the camp.
Nobody laughs quite long enough.
We have sat with a lot of families at the point where that joke stops being a joke. In our experience, the camp, the lake place or the hunting land ends more family relationships than money ever does. Not because anyone is greedy. Because the plan treated it like money, and it isn't.
Equal and fair are different words
Most estate plans divide things equally. Equal is simple, it is defensible and it feels right. With a brokerage account, it works. Three children, three equal shares, done.
A camp does not divide that way. Here is a hypothetical that looks a lot like families we know. Three adult children inherit a lake camp in equal shares. The oldest lives twenty minutes away and has spent every summer there. The middle child lives in Denver, comes up once every few years, and would rather have the cash. The youngest loves the place but cannot afford a third of the taxes, insurance and a new roof.
The plan was equal. The outcome is three people who now co-own something they feel very differently about, with no rules for who decides anything.
Fair might mean the local child gets the camp and the other two receive other assets of similar value. It might mean the camp is sold. It might mean everyone keeps it under a structure that works. Any of those can be right. The one that rarely works is equal shares with no agreement, because it hands the hardest decision to the people least able to make it together.
The questions the plan has to answer
Before anyone picks a structure, the family has to answer questions most plans never ask:
- Who gets to use it, and how is the calendar decided?
- Who pays the property tax, insurance, utilities and repairs, and what happens when someone does not pay?
- Who makes decisions, and how many votes does it take?
- How does someone get out, and at what price?
- Can a share pass to a spouse, an ex-spouse or a grandchild?
If your documents do not answer those, your children will answer them later, probably at a worse moment than Thanksgiving.
Tools families use
A family property LLC. A limited liability company, or LLC, is a legal entity that can own the camp instead of individual people owning it. Family members own shares of the LLC. The advantage is that the rules live in one document instead of in everyone's memory.
An operating agreement. This is the rulebook for the LLC. It covers use, costs, voting and, most important, how a member leaves. A good one sets a buyout price method in advance and gives the remaining family the first right to buy a departing member's share. It also limits who can become an owner, so the camp does not end up partly owned by someone's former spouse.
A funded maintenance reserve. Camps eat money. A roof, a septic system and a dock can all fail in the same decade. Setting aside money specifically for upkeep, often at the parents' death, keeps the youngest sibling from being forced out by a bill.
An equalization plan. If one child will keep the camp, other assets or life insurance can be used to give the other children something of comparable value. That is often the cleanest version of fair.
None of these are do-it-yourself documents. They should be drafted by an attorney who knows real estate and estate law in your state.
A Michigan detail that catches people
Michigan limits how much a property's taxable value can rise each year. When the property changes hands, that limit can reset, which is called uncapping, and the tax bill can jump sharply, especially on a camp that has been in the family for decades.
Current Michigan law exempts certain transfers of residential property to close relatives, such as a spouse or a child, as long as the use does not change. Grandchildren and siblings are generally not covered. And Michigan courts have treated some transfers of LLC ownership interests as a change of ownership even between parents and children. The order in which you do things, and the structure you use, can make a real difference to what your family pays every year afterward. Have your attorney confirm the current rules before anything is signed.
On the Wisconsin side: Wisconsin does not use this kind of cap, so there is no uncapping jolt at transfer. Everything else in this post applies equally on both sides of the border. And if your family has lived in both states, or owns property in the one you do not live in, that is its own conversation worth having with your attorney.
The conversation comes first
The documents are the easy part. The hard part is asking your children what the place means to them, and hearing the answer.
Some families learn the child they assumed would want the camp does not. Some learn the one who never says much has been counting on it. The families we have seen handle this well tend to have one thing in common: they had the conversation while everyone was still speaking to each other, with the parents in the room.
What to do before next summer
- Ask each child, separately, what they want for the property, and what they can realistically afford.
- Decide what fair means in your family, and write down why.
- Price out ownership. Taxes, insurance, utilities and a realistic repair budget for the next ten years.
- Talk with your attorney about whether an LLC, a trust or a simple sale fits, and about how your state treats the transfer.
- Fund the plan. A maintenance reserve, life insurance or other assets set aside for equalization.
- Have the first conversation at the camp, where everyone remembers why it matters.
Because this touches tax and legal questions, please consult a qualified tax advisor and attorney before acting on any of it.
Someone at your table is going to ask who gets the camp. The only choice you have is whether you are there to answer.
If your family owns property that matters more than its price, schedule an Exploratory Call with us. We will help you think it through with your attorney and CPA.
The opinions voiced in this material are for general information only and are not intended to provide specific advice or recommendations for any individual. This information is not intended to be a substitute for individualized legal advice. Please consult your legal advisor regarding your specific situation.